Skip to main content

Avoiding Metagaming with Character Actions - A Solo D&D Tutorial

In the first Episode of Season 2 of Tales of Mystara, I discussed some of my solo roleplaying mechanics, in an effort to help listeners better understand how I run my solo games. This is something I will try to do regularly in Season 2 and I figured it would make sense to include these short tips in this blog.

I have been asked on several occasions how I stop myself from metagaming, especially when running a pre-published aventure solo. This is actually a pretty easy thing to achieve, if you approach the problem of solo gaming in a certain way...

Avoiding Metagaming with Character Actions - A Solo D&D Tutorial

I've always approached the concept of playing D&D or other tabletop roleplaying games solo as a design problem that needs to be solved. For me, the problem is handled from three angles:

  • The first angle is to emulate the role of the Dungeon Master, so I can experience the game from the perspective of a player.
  • The second angle is to emulate player actions so I can experience the game from the perspective of the Dungeon Master.
  • The third angle is to provide a means to experience the game from the perspective of the observer.

I try to mix these three perspectives seamlessly so I can gain the ultimate tabletop fantasy roleplaying experience.

I think it’s easier to lose yourself in a world, if that world acts freely, of its own accord and you feel at each moment that you are along for the ride. If I can suspend my disbelief, immerse myself and be surprised and enchanted by each moment as it arises then I have achieved my goal.

By emulating player actions it’s easier to avoid metagaming. Metagaming, in this context for those who haven’t heard the term, is making use of knowledge learned outside of the game, that a character would not know.

To achieve player autonomy I tend to roll dice to determine which character will act in a given situation. A dice with sides equal to the number in the party will suffice, with any additional sides meaning they act as a party, but remember that sometimes actions the characters take might be quite obvious so there’s no need for a roll.

You’re probably wondering how randomly determining a character's actions affects logic. It’s important to remember that in these situations logic won’t always apply. For example, in a fantasy novel, characters tend to act very logically and tend to take the best possible action in a situation. In a group game of D&D this isn’t the case, players often do illogical things. They might try something goofy or make silly mistakes. That’s okay, it’s part of the fun of the game and often leads the story down surprising avenues. We tell great stories about these kinds of situations when we recall group games, so there’s every reason to have this in our solo games too!

To decide what a character does I roll on a table of common character actions. A simple d20, with each column having three entries to choose from. Things like “Hit, touch, look, or listen, attack, intimidate.” I simply choose the result that makes the most sense.

Here is an example:

  1. Climb, taste, cast
  2. Drink, throw, pray
  3. Eat, tie, capture
  4. Hit, touch, look
  5. Kill, turn, help
  6. Kiss, switch, heal
  7. Knock, unlock, hunt
  8. Lick, untie, forage
  9. Lay on, close, deceive
  10. Listen, attack, intimidate
  11. Lock, open, fire
  12. Move, break, persuade
  13. Pull, swim, perform
  14. Push, take, dodge
  15. Read, light, use
  16. Search, jump, charge
  17. Show, hide, cut
  18. Sit, give, evade
  19. Smell, sneek, feed
  20. Speak, steal, collect

Just some food for thought... Let me know what you think in the comments and be sure to check back for more content. In the meantime:

See you next session...

Support Me with a Donation

If you enjoy my content and find value in it and would like to send a small donation over to show your appreciation and help support this blog so it can continue to grow then please follow the link below to make a donation via PayPal.

https://paypal.me/tomdnd

Comments

  1. Hello, I have been following your channel for a while. I also want to get into solo RPG. Your method is really very interesting! I will try to apply it. But above all, I have to prepare the tables (and translate them into my usual language, French), as you did in your notebook in a video. Thank you very much for your work.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to Play Dungeons & Dragons Solo - Part 10 - Adventure Backgrounds, a Solo DnD Tutorial

I have some very functional procedures for generating coastlines, rivers, lakes, wilderness and dungeons, as well as interesting features, such as ruins, monuments, strange dwellings that exist off the beaten track, settlements both large and small and strongholds of different shapes and sizes. All this content along with the solo mechanics I have developed, make for a fairly satisfactory solo experience so far, but as I stated in the previous article: "the work is never done". There is still plenty to cover and plenty more things to be developed further. In particular, to create a deeper sense of immersion I want to look into methods for creating rich, immersive descriptions and backstory to help solidify my solo DnD game world so it can be brought to life. One important bit of backstory to be included is a background story to describe the adventure at hand, what is actually going on? What is the motivation for my character or party, why are they going on an adventure? An

How to Play Dungeons & Dragons Solo - Part 1 - Which Ruleset? A Solo DnD Tutorial

Hello and welcome to this blog. “ How to Play Dungeons & Dragons Solo ” . This blog will explore the concept of playing Dungeons & Dragons solo . This means playing the game completely by yourself with no Dungeon Master. The idea to write this blog naturally developed from a YouTube video series I created back in July 2020, dedicated to the process of how to start and run a Dungeons & Dragons solo campaign . I was increasingly requested to write all the information down to aid my viewers and provide something that brought all the information together in a concise format. How to Play Dungeons & Dragons Solo - Part 1 - Which Ruleset? A Solo DnD Tutorial In this blog I will present the information from the original videos (which I would advise watching in full as a reading accompaniment to obtain the full context) and expand upon it, showing you in further detail how to design and play a solo Dungeons & Dragons campaign by yourself with no involvement from

How to Play Dungeons & Dragons Solo - Part 3 - Dungeon Generation, a Solo DnD Tutorial

Welcome to my blog, How to Play Dungeons & Dragons Solo , dedicated to playing Dungeons & Dragons solo using Basic D&D rules. This series of blog posts is based on a YouTube video series I started back in July 2020 and is all about working out a way to play solo Dungeons & Dragons games . The aim is to develop a suitable rule system so that a game of D&D can be played without the need for any other players or a Dungeon Master. How to Play Dungeons & Dragons Solo - Part 3 - Dungeon Generation, a Solo DnD Tutorial In the first post I discussed the different iterations of the game, which are available, as well as which one would be the most suitable to use for a solo DnD campaign . I've decided to go with the BECMI Basic D&D rules written by Frank Mentzer and published in 1983. I also briefly talked about the stationary and equipment needed to play. I recommended the use of stationary over digital tools to encourage playing in an old school way, bu